March 20, 2024
XX Minute Read

Building a Robust Insider Threat Program: A Comprehensive Approach

With data breaches and cybersecurity incidents becoming increasingly common, the importance of an effective insider threat program cannot be overstated. Such programs are essential for protecting classified information, intellectual property, or otherwise sensitive information while ensuring the integrity of critical infrastructure. This guide outlines the crucial steps and considerations for developing a comprehensive insider threat program, integrating cybersecurity measures, and involving key stakeholders to mitigate insider threats effectively.

Key Elements of an Effective Insider Threat Program

The cornerstone of safeguarding against insider threats lies in understanding and implementing the key elements of an effective program. A robust insider threat program is not just a matter of IT security; it requires an integrated approach involving multiple departments such as human resources, general counsel, risk management, and physical security.

The program should begin with a clear, formalized structure encompassing mission statements, governance, directives, and budgeting. It's essential to ensure organization-wide participation, where each department understands its role and contributes to the program's effectiveness. Senior leadership must visibly support the program, especially for data that is compartmentalized in different organizational silos.

Moreover, the program must include oversight for compliance and effectiveness. This can be achieved through a governance structure, such as a working group or steering committee, to formulate standards, recommend procedural changes, and conduct audits or annual self-assessments. Confidential reporting mechanisms are vital for allowing employees to report suspicious activities safely and help the security function mitigate insider threat incidents over time.

{{ promo }}

Identify the needs of the insider threat program

Insider risks and insider threats are tied to the most basic elements of an organization’s security program – how does talent safely work with the organization’s information? Of all the many disciplines of cybersecurity, insider risk, and threat management are the most closely tied to the business itself. As such, organizations will ideally approach their insider threat program from the top to get direction and backing from executive leadership and align the program's goals with the unique needs and risks of the business.

Executive leadership. Organizational leaders will be able to provide key insight into the strategic needs of the program and help define the company’s expectations of how employees are expected to treat sensitive information.

HR teams. HR teams are typically strong contributors to an insider threat program. This can include defining the expected conduct of employees as it relates to data and privileged information. HR teams are also closely involved in all onboarding and offboarding activities of employees, which carry heightened risks for insider threats.

Legal teams. Legal teams have insight into any regulatory risks that the program should address. They may want to ensure that new employees don’t bring in sensitive data from a previous employer that could negatively impact the company. Legal teams may also want to understand how the program will affect end-user privacy and what types of evidence will be required if the organization intends to take legal action in response to an insider threat or insider attack. Are there any requirements for how an insider threat will need to be reported?

The Crucial Role of Stakeholders in Preventing Insider Threats

The stakeholders listed above play a crucial role in enabling your insider threat program and encouraging insider threat awareness across the organization. Senior management's support is especially indispensable. Their backing not only provides the necessary resources for the program's implementation but also promotes a culture of security and vigilance throughout the organization. Their engagement ensures that insider threat management is seen as a top priority.

In cases of severe insider threats that could jeopardize national security or involve criminal activities, collaboration with law enforcement becomes essential. Law enforcement agencies can provide expertise in investigating legal proceedings and help handle extreme cases of insider threats, such as espionage or sabotage.

Engage with the business

Next, the leaders of the insider threat program should engage with the individual business units. Sensitive data comes in many forms, and any data that could harm the organization if lost or exposed is potentially in scope of the insider threat program. Working with individual business units will help in the following ways:

  • Identify sensitive data or assets – Many business teams have an idea of what data needs to be protected. What information does the unit work with that would be valuable to a competitor? What data would be harmful or embarrassing if leaked to the public? This can help shift focus from a few simple records to documents, design files, source code, presentations, internal emails and chats, and more.
  • Identify any regulated data – The program will naturally need to know which parts of the business work with data subject to regulatory or compliance standards. This may include teams with administrative access to customer data or support services.
  • Identify business workflows – Knowing what data needs to be protected is only half the battle. Insider threat programs also need to know how the data is used to drive the business. This can include complex and open-ended workflows. Who needs the data? How is it shared? Are there unique issues, such as new product information that will be private and then made public after a launch?

Define how policies will be enforced

Next, organizations need to know exactly how the insider threat program will translate into action. This can require the organization to explicitly define its overall tolerance for risk. In developing the program, consider how the organization will balance the need to mitigate risks vs the need to maintain user productivity. Important questions can include:

  • Will the organization deploy measures to block the exfiltration or oversharing of data?
  • If blocking is not needed initially, will the capability be needed in the future?
  • Will users be allowed to override policies in order to maintain productivity?
  • What additional enforcement or response efforts are required? Manual investigation? Integration with SOAR or incident response platforms?
  • How will management be informed of events, and what actions will managers need to take after an event?

Build a user training program

The end users themselves are one of the most important aspects of insider threat program management, and all trusted insiders will need to be trained on the expectations and responsibilities for keeping company data safe and preventing unauthorized disclosure of sensitive information. This can include:

Documentation of policies. Providing users with the official company policies for handling data both in general as well as for their particular job role.

Periodic training. Providing cybersecurity training that includes best practices and requirements for preventing data loss.

Real-time training. Real-time coaching and training that can reinforce policies and redirect users in the context of their actual workflow.

These practices will serve as the basis of an insider threat awareness training program.

Tools and Techniques for Insider Threat Detection

In the realm of insider threat detection, the deployment of specific tools and techniques plays an essential role in identifying risk indicators and practicing insider threat mitigation more actively. The utilization of insider threat management software is paramount in this regard. This software aids in monitoring user activity and collecting detailed logs of each action within the network, providing invaluable data for security officers to review and analyze.

User activity monitoring is a critical component. It involves tracking and analyzing how employees access and use company data. Next-generation data detection and response (DDR) goes beyond data loss prevention to provide data security. DDR leverages data lineage to understand how user behavior and actions against data in your environments impact the content you deem sensitive information.

Learning from Case Studies and Directives

An invaluable resource in developing an insider threat program is the wealth of knowledge that can be gained from existing case studies and directives from organizations like the National Insider Threat Task Force (NITTF) and the Center for Development of Security Excellence (CDSE). These entities provide comprehensive frameworks and guidelines that can be adapted to the unique needs of different organizations.

Case studies, in particular, offer real-world examples of both successful and unsuccessful insider threat programs, offering insights into what strategies and tactics work and what pitfalls to avoid. These studies cover a range of scenarios, from accidental data leaks to malicious data theft, providing a broad understanding of the spectrum of insider threats.

In the complex and ever-evolving world of cybersecurity, insider threats– intentional or accidental – cannot be underestimated. Building a robust insider threat program is not just a matter of implementing technology; it requires a comprehensive approach that includes creating policies, conducting training, involving various stakeholders, and learning from existing case studies and directives.

An effective insider threat program is a collaborative effort that integrates cybersecurity practices into the core of business operations to address insider threat risk. By doing so, organizations can protect their critical assets, sensitive information, reputation, and financial stability. As threats evolve, so must the strategies to counter them, making continuous improvement and adaptation critical components of any successful program.

By following the guidelines and best practices outlined in this guide, organizations can establish a strong defense against insider threats, ensuring a secure and resilient operational environment.

Web page
Read our Cyberhaven for insider risk management overview
Learn more
Research report
Insider Risk Report Q1 2024: The Cubicle Culprits
Download now